What is DeskTop for?
If you don't need to manage files, or only ever run programs by booting floppy disks or running the amazing Total Replay, it's probably not for you.
Can I run DeskTop off of 5.25" floppies?
Technically yes, but you probably don't want to or need to. See the previous question. If you're not managing files on an 800k or larger ProDOS disk, you probably don't need Apple II DeskTop.
Also, there is only enough room for ProDOS and Apple II DeskTop on a 140k floppy disk, so you don't get any Desk Accessories. 140k disk images are available in the download packages, but they are really intended as a way to get the files onto your system to copy onto a hard drive.
Is DeskTop available in other languages?
Yes! Click the download link and you will find download packages available for the following languages:
Are there applications for Apple II DeskTop?
Yes and no...
Yes, any ProDOS app is compatible with DeskTop, whether it's AppleWorks, ShrinkIt, or MousePaint.
"But wait!" you say. "I mean GUI applications that run in DeskTop!"
What does that actually mean?
The original 128k Macintosh seemed revolutionary. Every application had the same look and feel. You started off in the Finder, and launched MacWrite. When you quit, you were back in the Finder. Then you launched MacPaint, edited a picture, and quit right back to the Finder. It seemed like you never left the desktop GUI provided by the Finder app. But... that was an illusion. Until systems had more memory and the MultiFinder was released several years later, the Finder was completely replaced in memory when another application was run, and reloaded when the other application exited. The experience was seamless because most applications took advantage of the GUI toolkit routines in ROM to present menus, windows, and so on. Sometimes this illusion was broken, such as early versions of MacPaint that didn't honor the desktop pattern, or games that didn't use the GUI.
The Apple II had no GUI toolkit routines in ROM. In 1985, two years after the Apple IIe was released and one year after the Macintosh launched, Apple produced the MouseGraphics ToolKit (MGTK) for the Apple IIe and later machines. This toolkit was loaded into RAM by applications to provide a GUI experience, and was used by DeskTop and a handful of other GUI apps. In theory, there could have been an extensive suite of ProDOS applications for the 8-bit Apple line that used the MGTK to provide a consistent experience. But this did not happen for a variety of reasons. Apple didn't promote MGTK heavily, perhaps because they wanted to encourage development on the new Macintosh platform. Text-mode applications like AppleWorks were already popular, and GUI applications tended to be much slower and consume more memory. And when the Apple IIgs was released in 1986 it attracted both the users and developers who desired a GUI experience for the Apple II line.
What other "GUI applications" exist for the Apple II?
While practically any Apple application that supported mouse input in text mode, ran in graphics mode, or ran under GEOS or GS/OS might technically qualify, this section will only list applications for 8-bit Apples that provide a menu-driven interface using a bitmapped graphics display and run under ProDOS. Note that most of these use their own GUI code, not MGTK.
MousePaint - Apple
8/16 Paint - Baudville
Dazzle Draw - Broderbund
Fantavision - Broderbund
TimeOut Paint (for AppleWorks) - Beagle Bros
Word Processing & Desktop Publishing
BeagleWrite (formerly MultiScribe) - Beagle Bros
II Write - Unicom/Random House
GS Font Editor - Beagle Bros (it runs on 8-bit Apples!)
Publish It! - Timeworks
Springboard Publisher - Springboard
Children’s Writing & Publishing Center - The Learning Company
Mouse Calc - Version Soft (yes, it's a GUI; it just looks like MouseText until a graph is displayed)
Family Matters - Springboard
Version Tel - Version Soft (hangs in Virtual ][ but works in MAME; French language)
Instant Pascal - Think Technologies, Inc (uses MouseGraphics ToolKit)
Atlas Explorer - Springboard
ChipWits - BrainPower
(This section is incomplete. Suggest more!)
Why use a GUI on the Apple II at all?
It is absolutely the case that a stock Apple II, with no accelerator and only floppy drives, is woefully underpowered for a GUI interface for most operations.
My current Apple II workflow is primarily emulator-based: Virtual ][ on a MacBook Air. I have a handful of curated virtual ProDOS hard disk images (games, apps, etc). When I want to use the "real thing" I copy the image files onto an SD card and boot the real Apple (actually, my Laser 128EX clone!) using a Floppy Emu. Since an emulator can run much faster than actual hardware, a GUI is no slower than a text-based interface to load or run.
Dragging and dropping files is also (at least for me) way faster than navigating menu structures in Copy II Plus.
How does Apple II DeskTop compare to Catalyst and GEOS?
Other GUI environments exist for the 8-bit Apples, including Quark Catalyst, another Mac-styled program launcher; and GEOS, a full blown GUI application environment and OS including productivity applications. How do they compare with Apple II DeskTop?
Some comparisons were published in popular magazines at the time, including:
A+ Magazine (March 1986, page 34): compares Catalyst 3.0 and Mouse Desk 1.0.
InfoWorld (March 1986, page 36): compares Catalyst 3.0 and Mouse Desk 1.0.
At a high level:
Catalyst is a program launcher, with a very Mac-like look and feel, but is not a file manager, or an integrated application environment.
DeskTop is a program launcher and file manager with a very Mac-like look and feel, but is not an integrated application environment.
GEOS is a program launcher, file manager, and integrated application environment, but doesn't have a Mac-like look and feel.
(This section is incomplete.)
How can I contribute to the project?
Apple II DeskTop development takes place on the GitHub Project. The goal of the project is to disassemble/reverse-engineer the suite with an eye towards understanding how it functions, fix bugs, and add functionality.